Why Payment Confusion Costs Businesses More Than They Realise

 

Payments should be straightforward. For many businesses, they are not.

Instead, payments are wrapped in unfamiliar terms, unclear responsibilities, and assumptions that go unchallenged. What starts as confusion quietly turns into real cost. Budget is wasted, decline rates rise, customer journeys suffer, and compliance becomes heavier than it needs to be.

Payments may feel unavoidable, but complexity is not. With the right understanding and the right partner, businesses can protect revenue, reduce avoidable costs, and stay in control of risk. In this blog, we discuss why clarity in payment services is crucial and clear up some common points of confusion. 

What Happens When Payment Processes Are Left Unquestioned

Many organisations pay more than they should for payment services simply because they do not fully understand what they are buying.

Payment setups are often inherited, bundled, or poorly explained at the outset, then left untouched. Over time, that lack of clarity turns into real cost.

This usually shows up in familiar ways:

  • Paying for features that never get switched on
  • Paying multiple providers for overlapping services
  • Accepting bundled pricing that hides poor value

But the impact goes beyond fees.

When payment problems are poorly understood, they become normalised. High decline rates are written off as bad luck or customer behaviour. Awkward handoffs between phone, web and IVR (Interactive Voice Response) are treated as the price of operating across channels. Slow or clunky agent workflows fade into the background.

Instead of being questioned, these issues are worked around.

Manual card handling can persist simply because it is familiar, even when safer and faster options exist. Lengthy PCI (Payment Card Industry) processes are accepted as unavoidable, rather than recognised as a sign of the wrong payment design. But over time, small monthly costs quietly drain budget. Friction builds into customer journeys. Teams spend more time managing problems than fixing them.

When terminology is unclear, it becomes harder to challenge proposals, spot duplication, or even define what good looks like. Improvement stalls, and avoidable issues linger far longer than they should.

A Common Area of Confusion: Payment Gateways and Acquiring Banks Are Not the Same Thing

One of the most common and costly sources of confusion in payments is treating the payment gateway and the acquiring bank as the same thing.

They are not.

A payment gateway controls how payments move through your systems. It manages the flow of data, connects channels such as web, phone and IVR, and determines how transactions are routed and retried.

An acquiring bank settles funds into your business bank account. It receives the authorisation code from the card issuer once the payment is approved and handles the charges and fees relating to that transaction.

When that distinction is unclear, businesses make long-term decisions on the wrong basis. They buy the wrong services, accept poor contracts, or assume change is harder than it really is.

When gateways and acquirers are treated as one, flexibility disappears. Switching providers becomes painful. Declines are harder to manage. Costs become harder to control.

Understanding the difference allows teams to design payment flows that work for them, not against them.

PCI Compliance Does Not Have to Dominate Your Thinking

PCI compliance is often seen as a constant headache, and that fear ends up driving decisions.

In response, businesses add heavier processes than they actually need. Internal controls grow. Agent workflows slow down. Customer journeys become more complex.

In reality, the right payment design can dramatically reduce PCI scope and effort. Many organisations carry far more compliance burden than necessary because they assume complexity is unavoidable, rather than questioning how payments are set up.

That assumption leads to:

  • Over-engineered processes
  • Excessive internal controls
  • Slower customer journeys

Clarity changes the conversation. It shifts the focus from “how do we cope with PCI” to “how do we design payments so PCI is easier by default”.

When Payments Are Clear, Better Decisions Follow

When teams understand how their payments actually work, everything changes.

Conversations become more direct. Vague promises are challenged. Providers are compared properly. Decisions move away from feature lists and towards real outcomes.

Instead of asking, “does this support X?”, teams ask, “what problem does this solve for us?”. That shift alone can prevent years of poor decisions, unnecessary cost, and locked-in complexity.

At Encoded, we believe payments should feel manageable, not intimidating. That means stripping away noise and focusing on how payments behave in the real world, across web, phone, IVR and agent-assisted journeys.

When payment design is done properly, the impact is practical and visible. Decline rates fall. Compliance becomes easier to manage. Agents and customers move through payments without friction. Costs are easier to control because the setup finally makes sense.

Payments should be easy to understand and easy to change. When they are, businesses make better decisions, and those decisions show up in stronger revenue, tighter cost control, and a better customer experience.

A Practical Next Step

If your payments feel harder to manage than they should, that is usually a sign of unnecessary complexity, not an unavoidable reality.

Taking a step back to understand how your payments are set up, what each component actually does, and where friction is being introduced often uncovers quick wins and longer-term improvements.

That is where better payment design starts. With clarity.

Talk to Encoded to review your payment setup and identify where confusion is costing you more than it should.

How will life pan out when long card numbers disappear?

How will life pan out when long card numbers disappear?

Rob Crutchington takes a look at what the future holds for Mail Order Telephone Order (MOTO) payments after long card numbers disappear and how to maintain personal customer connection in a digital world.Mastercard’s mandate(i) to phase out all Primary Account Numbers...

read more